The news
New publication “Participatory mapping of maritime uses as a pathway to inclusive Marine Protected Area governance”
Achieving the global “30×30” target (protecting 30% of marine space by 2030) is a critical challenge for ocean governance. However, accelerated efforts to meet these targets risk prioritizing spatial coverage over ecological coherence and social acceptance.
In our latest study published in npj Ocean Sustainability, a team from Future Oceans Lab (A. Blanco, C. van Rijs, S. Rayo-Luengo, H. Ayarza, and E. Ojea) investigated how participatory spatial mapping can inform zoning processes in complex, multi-use Marine Protected Areas (MPAs).
The Approach
We focused on the Parque Nacional Marítimo-Terrestre das Illas Atlánticas (PNMTIAG) in NW Spain, a contested marine space characterized by high human activity and historical difficulty in reaching consensus on management plans. Using the SeaSketch platform, we interviewed different stakeholders, including small-scale fishers, tourism operators, NGOs, and researchers, to capture four dimensions of the socioecological system:
-
The spatial distribution of economic activities.
-
Areas of perceived social conflict.
-
Levels of knowledge regarding management and agreement on expanded no-take areas.
-
Spatial trade-offs between stakeholder preferences and ecological values.
Key Findings
-
Conflict is More Than Spatial Overlap: Our results show that simply overlapping human activities does not necessarily lead to conflict. Instead, conflict structures are often asymmetric and driven by perceptions of legitimacy, fairness, and governance.
-
Moving Beyond Binary Protection: Stakeholders did not divide into simple “pro” or “anti” conservation camps. Instead, we identified nuanced preferences—such as support for temporary closures or habitat-oriented protection—that reflect distinct livelihood dependencies and cultural values.
-
Negotiating Trade-offs: Effective conservation relies on structuring how spatial trade-offs are revealed and negotiated. Our findings suggest that successful management requires iterative processes that integrate regulatory flexibility, ecological precision, and distributive fairness.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that achieving biodiversity targets depends not only on expanding strict protection but on sequencing and combining instruments in participatory ways that account for socioeconomic dependency and stakeholder trust. We advocate for adaptive, evidence-informed, and distribution-sensitive conservation design to improve the effectiveness and durability of our MPAs.
You can read the full article here: https://doi.org/10.1038/s44183-026-00223-z
CATEGORIES: Research
